1909 E90-1 American Caramel Eddie Plank PSA 6

1909 E90-1 American Caramel Eddie Plank PSA 6 – A Pop 6, Rare Portrait of Precision with None Graded Higher

Few pitchers in baseball history embodied control and consistency like Eddie Plank, and few cards capture his presence more vividly than the 1909 E90-1 American Caramel issue. Known for its rich colors and bold player depictions, the E90-1 set offered a dynamic contrast to the more muted tones of its tobacco-era counterparts. Plank’s entry in the set features a striking image of the Hall of Fame lefty in full windup, set against a deep red backdrop—a powerful aesthetic match for one of the game's quiet dominators.

This PSA 6 example stands at the top of the population, with only six graded at this level and none graded higher—a remarkable feat for a card now well over a century old. With strong color retention, crisp registration, and light, even wear that remains consistent with the grade, this card maintains outstanding eye appeal while preserving the historical integrity of the early caramel era.

As collectors of pre-war rarities know, E90-1 cards are notoriously difficult to find in high-grade condition due to fragile cardstock and limited regional distribution. Plank’s presence in the set elevates its prestige even further. Often overshadowed by the mystique of his T206 counterpart, the E90-1 Plank offers an alternative visual and scarcity narrative that has gained increasing traction among advanced collectors.

This card is more than just a condition rarity—it’s a tribute to one of baseball’s earliest masters, captured in a set that helped usher in the golden age of caramel issues. For those seeking top-of-the-line Deadball Era cardboard, this Pop 6 PSA 6 represents a truly elite opportunity.