1958 Topps #74 Leo Nomellini PSA 9

1958 Topps #74 Leo Nomellini PSA 9 – A Hall of Fame Trenches Titan in Stunning Condition

By 1958, Leo Nomellini was already a living legend in the NFL, a ten-time All-Pro and the unquestioned leader of the San Francisco 49ers’ defensive front. As a two-way lineman, he was a rare breed—capable of dominating on both offense and defense, making him one of the most feared and respected players of his era. Known for his unmatched durability, raw strength, and relentless motor, Nomellini never missed a single game in his 14-season career, earning enshrinement in the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1969. Beyond football, he was also a professional wrestler, bringing the same intensity to the ring that he did to the gridiron.

This 1958 Topps #74 Leo Nomellini is a gorgeous PSA 9 example, making it one of the highest-graded copies in existence from a set that is notorious for print defects and centering issues. The bold colors, crisp imagery, and clean edges showcase Nomellini’s larger-than-life presence, while the centering is exceptional, the corners are razor-sharp, and the surface remains immaculate. With only a handful of PSA 9s in circulation and only one graded higher, this is a true rarity for collectors of vintage football cards.

For collectors of Hall of Fame linemen, San Francisco 49ers history, or high-grade vintage football cards, this Leo Nomellini PSA 9 is an absolute must-have. As one of the most dominant forces in football history, Nomellini’s legacy continues to loom large, and this card serves as a fitting tribute to one of the toughest and most versatile players to ever step onto an NFL field.