1887 N172 Old Judge Stephen Toole PSA 5

1887 N172 Old Judge Stephen Toole PSA 5 – A Rare Gem from Baseball’s Earliest Era

The 1887 N172 Old Judge Stephen Toole card is a fascinating relic from the dawn of professional baseball and one of the most celebrated sets in hobby history. The N172 Old Judge series, issued by Goodwin & Company, stands as the first major baseball card set, capturing the pioneers of the sport in stunning photographic detail. Stephen Toole, an early-era player, is featured here in one of the game’s most iconic designs, offering collectors a tangible link to baseball’s origins.

This PSA 5 example is an extraordinary specimen for a card that has survived over 135 years. The image clarity is exceptional, showcasing Toole in striking detail for the era, with clean edges and impressive corner retention. The sepia-toned photography and timeless design highlight the artistry of the Old Judge set, widely regarded as the gold standard for 19th-century baseball cards. Cards of this vintage and quality are exceedingly rare, making this a significant piece of both baseball and collecting history.

For those who value early baseball memorabilia, this 1887 N172 Stephen Toole is an exceptional find. Its rarity, high grade, and connection to the origins of the sport make it a centerpiece for any advanced collection. Owning a card from the Old Judge set is more than a hobby milestone—it’s a journey into the roots of America’s pastime.